The Contradictions In Western Idea Of Freedom Of Speech And The Islamic Perspectivew3badmin
The number one source of information that the humans of West have for gaining information about Islam is Western media. each the print and electronic media of West is what offers facts to the humans about Islam and it’s far the biasness of this media that the human beings of the West have a bad perception of Islam and they see it as a faith of oppression and aggression.
one of the foremost things that Islam is accused of within the Western international is the oppression of freedom of speech. West broadcasts to be the proponent and the emblem bearer of freedom of speech, whereas it regards Islam as a faith wherein the fans haven’t any say by any means and that they cannot boost their voice in opposition to some thing.
The Islamic opinion about the freedom of speech could be discussed in later a part of the writing but, the thing that wishes to be addressed first is the Western view of freedom of speech and the way it contradicts with it.
The West is the proponent of freedom of speech wherein the individuals in a society are loose to express their opinion in any manner they need in opposition to or for anybody they want. although this sort of freedom can’t exist in global because one of these freedom could bring about nothing but human beings defaming every other, spreading slanders and falsely accusing each other. therefore, inside the Western law, in spite of all of the freedom, the restrict of it is set that it does no longer bring about hurting the feeling of anybody or that harms the photo of a few other man or woman.
The West speaks of freedom of speech with none barriers, but, it indicates biasness closer to certain matters and for them it has made laws, whereas, with regards to different social systems within the global like Islam, they decide it and defame it for the bounds it has placed on its fans. some principal contradiction of the West touching on the liberty of speech it so claims are as follows:
firstly, in the eu nations there may be a law as consistent with which nobody is permitted to talk approximately ant-Semitic motion in the Nazi regime. human beings aren’t allowed to desire the haulocast or give any opinion that doesn’t oppose it. This indicates the biasness of the Western media and the demolishing of the perception of freedom of speech. on the other hand, with regards to Western media publishing the caricature of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and Muslims protesting towards it, it’s miles virtually remarked as a freedom of expression. hence, duality and contradiction exist inside the Western perception of freedom of speech.
Secondly, in CIA all of the employees are bound to signal a file as according to which they’re never to share or to publish their enjoy that entails information related to united states. This regulation turned into passed when CIA officers commenced writing memoirs concerning their enjoy at some point of carrier. despite the fact that that turned into their expression however, it did not suit the usa objective consequently, it turned into taken away from the officials. therefore, some other contradiction in Western announcing and doing.
Thirdly, in uk as well the officials of the name of the game organization are not allowed to discuss or publish any information relating country wide security. as a result, their freedom of speech is also made restricted.
The above arguments show that the West speaks of freedom of speech with none constraints, however, in relation to sure topics and problem, there may be no freedom of speech in any respect and there are strict limitations.
Islam is a religion of moderation and human connection. It does not allow whatever that is extreme or that tarnishes the human connection. Islam lets in its followers to talk freely and in a few instances it stresses upon them to talk without any fear, but, in relation to speech hurting the emotions or beliefs of someone, Islam tells it fans to chorus from it and undertake a manner this is extra diffused. a few examples of how Islam views freedom of speech and to what quantity does it permits Muslims to proclaim their opinion are as follows:
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) stated in a hadith:
“The master of martyrs is Hamza bin Abdul Muttalib and a man who stood up to an oppressive ruler, ordered him (to do good) and forbade him (from doing evil) and was killed by him.”
The hadith indicates that in terms of talking freely, the allowed speech is that which inspires or promotes goodness and that forbids evil. consequently, Muslims are to elevate their voices without any worry in the event that they see some thing awful going on and they must also inspire or guide goodness with their voice.
Harun-ul-Rashid became one of the Muslim caliphs who rewarded scholars who could go out and spread the message of Islam and give human beings an understanding of deen. therefore, speech for the sake of spreading of knowledge is also allowed and endorsed in Islam.
Thirdly, on contrary to the Western international wherein freedom of speech is permitted in relation to hurting the emotions of the Muslims, Islam forbids any act that hurts the feeling of the non-Muslims living within the Muslims reign. concerning this, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) stated in one in every of His hadiths:
“Whoever hurts a non-Muslim citizen of an Islamic state hurts me, and he who hurts me annoys Allah.” (Bukhari )
From the hadith it’s far clean that during Islam any proclamation of speech this is against any religion or that hurts the sensation of a non-Muslim is not allowed in Islam. consequently, the belief that Islam or Muslims one way or the other are in competition of non-Muslims or they go to any measures to defame other religions is wrong, alternatively Islam wishes Muslims to accept that other humans have their faith and there is no want of turning closer to hurtful speech as a means of spreading Islam.
Ina nutshell, there’s no such aspect as an ideal freedom of speech inside the global and if West does pontificate any it’s miles constrained and wherever it conflicts with the super scheme the proper of speech is taken again from the respective humans. Islam encourages a speech this is in favor of correct and that detests awful, however, even then the speech is meant to be unfastened from any hate and resentfulness. We can only take the right path with ALLAH’s will and by following his Book, Quran. We should always refer to Quran, but know what’s written in it we need to learn quran with tajweed for better understanding.